A Life In Fragments

Home » My Research Trips » Fragments of the PAS: Dorset

Fragments of the PAS: Dorset

Follow A Life In Fragments on WordPress.com

Dorset is a particularly interesting place within my study region. It straddles a geological boundary of the sandstone that dominates Devon, Cornwall and much of Somerset, and the chalklands that characteristic Wiltshire and Hampshire. At least half of the county (the eastern half) falls under the traditional ‘Wessex’ landscape. What this means is that the character of the metalwork, and indeed other materials, is quite broad and often unique within the south western region.

The PAS material to a certain extent reflects this. Over 100 findspots are recorded on the PAS database, comprising about around 130 objects. As is typically the case in Dorset, there are few hoards or multiple finds of metal objects. Instead, the focus is on individual deposits. Numerous finds of goldwork have come up, indicating traditions of certain object types that are rarely seen in other parts of south west England. However, like the rest of the region, axes are prolific, often in a fragmentary state, and spearheads occur in similar numbers as in Devon.

This post starts by focusing on predominantly complete objects, but never fear there’s a decent amount of both deliberate and accidental fragmentation thrown in towards the end!

Gold Rings

Numerous small gold penannular rings have been found in Dorset recently. The exact function of these rings is uncertain but they occur in a variety of forms, and may be solid gold, or may have a clay or copper alloy core that is covered with gold sheet. Sometimes there are ornamented with bands of gold and electrum along the surface, representing a skilled technical process. Previously none were known from the south west, but now a total of sixteen have been found, with many found through the PAS scheme. This find from Osmington (DOR-18E227) shows the beautiful banding that was achieved.

PAS-P139 Osmington

Image courtesy of the Portable Antiquities Scheme

Bournemouth Palstave hoard (2011 T589)

In 2011, a hoard of six complete palstaves and one palstave blade fragment was found. This hoard included a mixture of palstave forms, including a south-western type, southern English types and a Norman form, broadly dating to the Taunton phase of the Middle Bronze Age. The palstave fragment had broken in antiquity and likely represented accidental damage through use (click the images for larger versions!)

Frampton arrowhead (WILT-8171F0)

A rare copper alloy arrowhead has been found while metal-detecting near Frampton. It more or less takes the form of typical Early-Middle Bronze Age flint barbed and tanged arrowheads. Only a handful of bronze examples are known from the country so far, and this is the first of its kind in south west England. It hints towards the idea that there were probably object types present in prehistory that were never deposited and thus we never recover them.

PAS-P118 Frampton II

Image courtesy of the Portable Antiquities Scheme

Tarrant Valley Gold lunula (DOR-2198F8)

The gold lunula from the Tarrant Valley is the first of its kind from Dorset. These large ornaments are more typical of Ireland, Cornwall and France. A large piece of it (approx. three-quarters) was found in 2014, as well as a small fragment. However, one terminal was missing. In 2015, a crumpled terminal fragment was found nearby and is believed to be the missing terminal. It is likely these damages are the result of ploughing, rather than deliberate breakage in the past. This amazing object can be seen at Dorchester County Museum (click the images for larger versions!)

Shillingstone rapiers (WILT-8CBFA4)

Rapiers are relatively rare in Dorset, especially when compared with Devon, which appears to have had a minor rapier industry. Two rapiers found at Shillingstone are thus an important contribution to understanding object distribution. They are especially important for my research as one was found in three refitting fragments, while the second was found in six fragments. On the face of it, one would be forgiven for thinking this fragmentation was deliberate destruction. However, while at least one of the breaks on each rapier is seemingly the result of intent, the other damages are related to post-deposition processes, such as corrosion. This is indicated by associated damage (e.g. bending) and the state of the breaks. This highlights the importance of understanding differences in breakage patterns (click the images for larger versions!)

 

Endnote and Acknowledgements

This is the third post in my series on the pieces I’ve been studying from the Portable Antiquities Scheme database. Be sure to check out my other posts on Devon and Cornwall! My thanks must go to Dorset County Museum who have allowed me access to see some of this material.

About Me

DSC02567I’m Matt, 26 years old, a glutton for academic punishment, a lover of all things Bronze Age, always willing to continue talking even when my friends have lost interest, and never happy unless overwhelming busy. Find out more here and be sure to follow me on Twitter @mgknight24 and Facebook.

Advertisements

8 Comments

  1. […] from the Portable Antiquities Scheme database. Be sure to check out my other posts on Cornwall and Dorset! My thanks must go to Danielle Wootton (the FLO for Devon) for her help, as well as Thomas Cadbury […]

    Like

  2. […] posts on Cornwall, Devon and Dorset are now available for your viewing pleasure with Somerset following in the next couple of […]

    Like

  3. […] If you enjoyed this post, why not check out my others on the PAS material from Devon and Dorset! […]

    Like

  4. Oliver says:

    Great finds, especially the palstave hoard (from my biased perspective :-)). Do you have any idea what the whitish concretions visible in the area of fracture are?

    Liked by 1 person

    • mgknight21 says:

      I think they are a combination of mineral inclusions in the casting and/or stones that have become embedded in the corrosion after deposition during the formation processes. But I haven’t actually handled most of these so I can’t be sure! Your thoughts would be much appreciated! (Apologies for the delayed response!)
      Also, if you like palstave hoards… have you heard of the Marnhull hoard?

      Liked by 1 person

      • Oliver says:

        Some alloy materials can form ‘lakes’ within the matrix when they occur in (too) high concentrations. Lead is a good example for this, and because of the greyish/whitish colour I was thinking about this possibility. Artfefacts also tend to break in the areas, where these lakes form. But mineral inclusions in the corrosion layers are also a good possibility, it’s really hard to judge from the photos.
        I haven’t heard of the Marnhull hoard, is there something to be found on the internet about it?

        Liked by 1 person

      • mgknight21 says:

        How interesting. I didn’t know this. You’re unlikely to find much (if any info) on the Marnhull hoard online. It’s a hoard of 90 palstaves that was found in Dorset in 1989. 89 of them are complete and they represent mostly Norman/Norman-influenced palstaves, plus about 25 Breton style. So clearly an import from northern France. It was published in a brief note in the Dorset Society proceedings though with no pictures. If you’re interested, PM me on Twitter with your email address and I can send you a scanned copy of the paper.

        Liked by 1 person

      • Oliver says:

        Thanks, will do!

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: